Lease, loan or buy: Funding heavy equipment upgrades on a tight cash flow
Sponsored content. This article was supplied by a third party and Business Money has been paid to publish it.
Photo by Money Knack on Unsplash
Is your electrical equipment aging out faster than the budget can replace it?
That’s where many plant owners and facilities managers find themselves today. Breakers are worn out, equipment has exceeded its service life, and the estimate you just received quotes a price that sends your finance department into deep silence.
The good news?
Cash isn’t the only way to pay bills, either. Three funding routes — lease, loan or buy — exist, and choosing the correct one can mean the difference between a seamless install or an entire year of begging and pleading.
What you’ll walk away with:
- Why the price tag keeps climbing
- Leasing: the cash flow friendly route
- Equipment loans: ownership without the big cheque
- Buying outright: when cash still wins
- Choosing the right option for your site
Why this bill keeps getting bigger
Electrical infrastructure isn’t getting cheaper. And it’s definitely not getting faster.
Data centre growth + grid rebuilds + reshoring have absorbed much of the manufacturing capacity available in the market. The lead times reflect that. Some medium voltage equipment has lead times of over a year. Transformers are far worse — lead times grew from three to six months in 2019 to 12 to 30 months by 2023, and have hardly improved since.
Facilities located in seismic zones take on another level of complexity above and beyond. Seismic qualified switchgear must be shake-table tested and certified to operate after an event rather than just remain upright. All that certification requires additional engineering hours, paperwork and lead time for your order. That’s why many project teams specify compact gas-insulated switchgear for these projects. A sealed unit with a smaller footprint is much easier to brace, anchor and incorporate into a seismic qualified switchgear suite without having to redesign the room.
But here’s the part that catches people out…
Every month spent debating how to pay gets another month tacked onto the delivery date. For long lead gear, the decision to fund is the decision to schedule.
Leasing: The cash flow friendly route
Leasing is when you pay for the use of equipment owned by someone else. The equipment is installed and operational, and the expense shows up as a monthly operating expense rather than a large dent in the budget.
So why do so many operators choose this route? Because it preserves working capital. Cash is retained in the business for payroll, materials and the projects that will actually generate revenue.
Leasing tends to work well when:
- Cash reserves are thin but the equipment can’t wait
- The technology might need upgrading in 5-10 years
- Payments need to be predictable for budgeting
- The equipment supports a contract with a fixed end date
The downside? Over the entire term, you will typically pay far more than if you bought. And when it’s up, you don’t own anything, unless you put a buyout option in the contract.
Having said that, some leases include maintenance and service in the payment. For essential distribution equipment that must remain powered up, a service contract built into the monthly dollar amount is money well spent.
Equipment loans: Ownership without the big cheque
An equipment loan falls somewhere in between. You borrow it, install it and own the equipment. The lender just holds a lien on the equipment until the note is paid in full.
Here’s what most of the market does. Over 8 out of 10 U.S. businesses finance some type of equipment purchase. And businesses are borrowing even more. In December, companies borrowed 5.9% more than they did the previous year for equipment purchases.
Here’s why loans appeal so much to owners of long-life assets:
Switchgear is not a laptop computer. With good maintenance a line-up can last 25-30 years. Financing something with a five year note that operates for thirty years means you have 25 years of use where you make no payments on the asset. That math doesn’t wash.
Loans make sense when:
- The equipment has a genuinely long service life
- The business plans to stay in the building
- Cash flow is steady enough to carry a monthly payment
- Depreciation deductions matter to the tax position
The problem is the down payment. Lenders typically require 10-20% downpayment along with good credit and a few years decent financials. This excludes many newer businesses.
Buying outright: When cash still wins
Sometimes writing the cheque is simply the right call.
Cash out purchases eliminates interest, monthly payment and puts the asset onto your balance sheet right away. No lender to get approval from, no covenants to worry about, no endless chain of paperwork. Place order, that’s it.
A cash purchase is usually best when:
- The company is sitting on healthy reserves
- The purchase is small relative to annual revenue
- The supplier offers a real discount for paying upfront
- Borrowing costs are painfully high
However, don’t empty the account to accomplish that. If a business maxes out it’s reserves on an upgrade only to suffer a sluggish quarter, they have simply traded one issue for a far larger one. The guideline that most operators follow is very basic. Never allow one expenditure to drop reserves below 3-6 months of expenses.
How to choose the right route
Forget which option sounds cheapest. Work through these four questions instead.
How long will the equipment actually be used?
Long-life assets favour ownership. Anything likely to be obsolete inside a decade favours leasing.
What does cash flow look like on a bad month?
Not a good month. Nope. Bad month. If payments are hurting during a down month, either lengthen up or restructure prior to signing anything.
What happens if the old gear fails first?
This is actually the question people often miss. Unscheduled downtime is far more expensive than the financing costs of any of these options. If obsolete equipment is a single point of failure at your site, the least expensive funding option is whatever will have replacement equipment ordered now.
What does the accountant say?
Leases and loans are treated very differently for book purposes. Deductions/depreciation/Section 179 can greatly alter the true cost. A few minutes conversation before signing could save you a lot of money later.
Putting the plan together
Lets face it. There isn’t a right answer here. There’s only the right answer for that one site, that one balance sheet, that one delivery window.
Leasing preserves cash. Loans create equity. Purchasing eliminates interest and payments altogether. But each of those three options is better than option four: doing nothing and silently hoping your old equipment doesn’t fail tomorrow.
With lead times sitting where they are, hoping is expensive.
Get the spec finalised, get a firm quote, match funding route to cash flow. In that order. The gear is going to take months to arrive no matter what. Might as well spend those months waiting on a delivery truck rather than waiting on someone’s decision.